Skip to content

Independent. Reader-funded. No advertising. Since 1984.

How we are funded

Makeup Lab test

Under-Eye Concealers for Mature Skin

Eight under-eye concealers from $8 to $78. On mature skin, we assess creasing, brightening and wear at 2, 6 and 10 hours.

Products selected
8
Price range
$8 to $78
Scored out of
100
Results
Pending

Why we are testing these

The under-eye area is the hardest place on the face to conceal. The skin there is among the thinnest on the body, it moves with every expression, and after 40 it develops fine lines, hollows and a darker tone that comes from thinning skin and visible blood vessels as much as from pigment. A concealer that covers well often creases within an hour; one that stays smooth may be too sheer to brighten the darkness underneath.

Brands answer with different promises. Some sell brightening formulas with caffeine, peptides or hyaluronic acid and quote clinical results; others sell full-coverage, long-wear products with 16- or 24-hour claims. Coverage, finish and texture are described with words such as radiant, satin and creamy that mean different things in different lines, and undertone matters even more than with foundation, because the wrong one turns gray or ashy over dark circles. Prices run from $8 at the drugstore to $78 for a prestige stick.

We test eight concealers under the eyes of women with mature skin, to see which stay put through a working day, which brighten without emphasizing lines, and whether the skincare claims add anything measurable.

What we look for

  • Creasing into fine lines under the eye at 2, 6 and 10 hours, recorded with standardized imaging
  • Coverage of dark circles without a gray or ashy cast across light, medium and deep skin tones
  • Oxidation and fading through the day, and transfer to glasses and fingertips
  • Texture on dry, thin skin: whether it drags, cakes or emphasizes texture
  • Named actives such as caffeine, peptides and hyaluronic acid, and where they sit on the ingredient list
  • Applicator hygiene, and how much usable product the price buys

Free preview

The 8 products in this test

Listed alphabetically by brand, not ranked. The facts below come from each brand's own published information. Our own measurements will appear in the results.

  • Charlotte Tilbury

    Beautiful Skin Radiant Concealer

    $36 10 g Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    niacinamide · hyaluronic acid · vitamin C (the brand calls it golden vitamin C) · medium-buildable coverage; radiant, natural-looking finish

    What the brand says

    • Hydrating, medium-buildable coverage with a radiant, natural-looking finish, according to the brand
    • Sweat-proof and waterproof with 16-hour wear, according to the brand
    • Brand cites 93% agreeing dark circles appear reduced over time
    • Brightening and smoothing, according to the brand
  • Clé de Peau Beauté

    Concealer SPF 27

    $78 Prestige

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    SPF 27 (sunscreen filters not listed on the page) · skin-first ingredients, according to the brand (not named on the page) · full coverage stick; radiant finish

    What the brand says

    • Full-coverage stick with 16-hour longwear and a radiant, crease-resistant finish, according to the brand
    • Brand says it conceals while improving smoothness, radiance and hydration
    • Light-control technology for a radiant finish, according to the brand
  • Dior

    Dior Forever Skin Correct

    $42 0.37 oz Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    iris extract (hydrating, according to the brand) · wild pansy extract · yarrow extract (brightening and smoothing, according to the brand) · 96% natural-origin ingredients, according to the brand · full coverage; creamy texture

    What the brand says

    • Full coverage with 24-hour wear and hydration, according to the brand (instrumental tests on 27 and 31 subjects)
    • Transfer-proof; brand says it resists heat and humidity
    • Brand says it smooths the complexion without settling into facial lines
    • Hides under-eye circles, redness, pigment spots and blemishes, according to the brand
  • e.l.f.

    Hydrating Camo Concealer

    $8 Drugstore

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    no skincare actives named on the brand page · full coverage; satin finish

    What the brand says

    • Full coverage with a satin finish, according to the brand
    • Crease-resistant and long-lasting, according to the brand
    • Brand says it covers blemishes and under-eye circles while delivering a boost of hydration
    • 25 shades with a shade-match guarantee
  • Kosas

    Revealer Concealer

    $32 0.18 oz (5.3 mL) Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    caffeine · arnica · panthenol · hyaluronic acid · peptides · medium, buildable coverage; fresh, hydrated, radiant finish

    What the brand says

    • Medium, buildable coverage in an eye-cream base, with a fresh, hydrated, radiant finish, according to the brand
    • Brand says it is clinically proven to improve bare skin over time and reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles
    • Silicone-free, non-comedogenic and safe for sensitive skin, according to the brand
    • 38 shades on the brand site
  • Maybelline

    Instant Age Rewind® Eraser Multi-Use Concealer

    $12.99 0.2 fl oz Drugstore

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    Haloxyl (the brand's dark-circle ingredient) · moisturizing formula; vegan, mineral oil-free, paraben-free, talc-free and non-comedogenic, according to the brand · medium coverage; moisturizing finish

    What the brand says

    • Up to 12 hours of moisturizing wear, according to the brand
    • Crease-resistant; brand says it does not settle into fine lines and wrinkles
    • Multi-use: conceals, color corrects, contours and highlights, according to the brand
    • Cushion applicator
  • NARS

    Radiant Creamy Concealer

    $36 0.22 oz (6 mL) Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    Multi-Active Botanical Blend, according to the brand · medium, buildable coverage; radiant finish

    What the brand says

    • Medium, buildable coverage with a radiant finish and 16-hour wear, according to the brand
    • Crease-resistant; brand cites 90% agreeing it leaves a creaseless finish
    • Brand says it gives 24 hours of hydration and visibly firms
    • 30 shades
  • Westman Atelier

    Vital Skincare Concealer

    $48 0.09 oz (2.5 g) Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    hyaluronic acid · peptides · Vital Wakeup Complex, according to the brand · medium to full coverage; airy, supernatural finish

    What the brand says

    • Medium to full coverage that brightens, blurs and sets in seconds, according to the brand
    • Brand says it is clinically shown to reduce dark circles under the eyes in four weeks
    • No added fragrance; non-comedogenic; dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, according to the brand
    • 16 shades (D1-4, L1-4, M1-4, T1-4)

Prices are the brands' US list prices, checked on November 17, 2026, and may have changed. We carry no shopping links and earn nothing when you buy.

How we test

We buy every concealer at retail at full price, matched to each panelist with the brand’s shade tools. Nothing is accepted from brands. A panel of 20 to 30 women aged 38 to 65, with light to deep skin tones and a range of undertones, wears each concealer under the eyes as directed for four weeks, blinded to brand and in randomized order, over her usual skincare and without powder unless the brand instructs it.

On standardized wear days we photograph the under-eye area under controlled lighting before application and at 2, 6 and 10 hours. Images are graded for creasing into fine lines, coverage of dark circles, oxidation and fading, and any gray or ashy cast against each skin tone; a transfer test presses a white cloth to the area at each interval. Corneometry before application and at 10 hours records whether the formula dries the skin. Panelists rate blending, texture on dry skin and comfort.

Marcus Bauer, PhD, audits each ingredient list for the actives the brand names, checks preservation and assesses the applicator for hygiene. Laura Schmidt, MD, FRCP supervises the clinical testing. Scores follow the four ABR criteria, Efficacy (40), Formula (25), Feel and use (20) and Value (15), and are reviewed by the Scientific Board.

The four criteria

40Efficacy
Measured change against baseline: hydration, elasticity, wrinkle depth, pigmentation, SPF verification or wear performance, depending on the category.
25Formula
Ingredient audit: evidence behind the actives, stated concentrations, stability and packaging that protects them.
20Feel & use
Texture, absorption, scent, layering under other products, tolerance reported by the panel.
15Value
What the measured performance costs per month at the brand's list price.

Our full testing method

Who runs this test

Subscriber content

The results

Laboratory results for this test have not been published yet. When they are, the scores, ranking and findings for all 8 products will be available to subscribers.

  • A score out of 100 for every product, across four criteria
  • The ranking, with the Test Winner and every Highly Rated product
  • Measured findings and a plain-English verdict for each product

See subscription plans

Subscriptions are opening soon. Join the waiting list to be told first.

Lab tests

All lab tests

Subscriptions opening soon

Paid for by readers. Answerable to no one else.

A subscription will open the full results of all 50 lab tests: every score, every ranking and every finding. $7.99 a month or $59 a year, cancel anytime.

See what a subscription includes

Join the waiting list

One email when subscriptions open. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy.