Makeup Lab test
Mascaras: The Flake Test
Seven mascaras from $13.99 to $45, tubing and traditional formulas. We assess flaking, smudging and comfort on lashes that have thinned with age.
- Products selected
- 7
- Price range
- $13.99 to $45
- Scored out of
- 100
- Results
- Pending
Why we are testing these
Lashes become sparser, shorter and lighter with age, and the skin around the eyes becomes thinner and drier at the same time. That combination is why mascara is so often the product women over 35 complain about: a formula that looked fine at 30 now flakes onto the cheekbone by afternoon, smudges into the lines under the eye, or feels heavy on lashes that have less strength to carry it. Removing it at night is its own problem on delicate skin.
The market has split into two broad types. Traditional wax-based mascaras build volume but can shed; tubing mascaras wrap each lash in a polymer film that is meant to hold until it is slid off with warm water. Brands on both sides claim 24-hour wear, no flaking and no smudging, and some add conditioning ingredients or fibers with claims of visible length. Few explain how those claims were measured.
We chose seven mascaras sold in the US, from drugstore classics to a $45 formula from a prestige house. No mascara at the brands we considered costs more than $60, so the price spread is narrower than in most of our tests. We buy every tube at retail and set out to measure what stays on the lashes and what ends up on the face.
What we look for
- Flaking onto the cheeks and smudging under the eyes at 2, 6 and 10 hours, scored from standardized close-up images
- Visible length, volume and separation immediately after application, compared with the bare-lash baseline
- Clumping during application and whether the formula builds evenly on sparse lashes
- Eye comfort through the day, including irritation, dryness and watering reported by panelists
- Ease and gentleness of removal, and how much product is left on the lashes afterward
- Full ingredient list, wand design, and price per gram or fluid ounce
Free preview
The 7 products in this test
Listed alphabetically by brand, not ranked. The facts below come from each brand's own published information. Our own measurements will appear in the results.
-
Clinique
Lash Power Tubing Mascara Long-Wearing Formula
$28 Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
tubing formula · thermal (warm-water) removal · 2 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says it is a lash-lengthening tubing mascara with 24-hour wear
- Smudge-proof; lasts through sweat, humidity and tears
- Removes with warm water, no makeup remover needed
-
Dior
Diorshow Iconic Overcurl
$35 Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
cornflower floral water · refillable · 3 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says it gives spectacular volume and curl that lasts 24 hours
- Intense, long-wearing color that is smudge-proof
- Refillable; the formula is said to help nourish and visibly fortify lashes
-
L'Oréal Paris
Telescopic Lift Washable Mascara
$15.99 0.33 oz Drugstore
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
Double Hook brush · washable formula
What the brand says
- Brand says it gives instant lift, volume and up to 5 mm of added visible length
- Up to 36-hour wear
- Removes easily with soap and water; described as suitable for sensitive eyes
-
Lancôme
Lash Idôle Mascara
$30 Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
lightweight gel formula · curved wand with 360 micro-bristles
What the brand says
- Brand says it lifts and fans out lashes for an open-eye effect lasting up to 24 hours
- Lightweight gel formula with no flaking or smudging all day
- 90% saw clump-free lashes (brand consumer study)
-
Maybelline New York
Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara
$13.99 Drugstore
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
bamboo extract · Flex Tower brush · washable formula · 9 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says it delivers limitless length and full volume
- Long-lasting, lightweight washable formula infused with bamboo extract
- Removes with a gentle makeup remover or micellar water
-
Thrive Causemetics
Liquid Lash Extensions Tubing Mascara
$26 0.38 oz (10.7 g) Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
tubing formula · Orchid Stem Cell Complex · 8 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says the tubing formula wraps each lash in lightweight tubes for length and definition
- Water-resistant, smudge-proof and flake-free, yet slides off with warm water
- Orchid Stem Cell Complex is said to support longer, healthier-looking lashes over time
-
Westman Atelier
Eye Want You Mascara
$45 0.29 fl oz (8.5 mL) Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
plant-based wax blend (carnauba and candelilla) · shea butter · hourglass-shaped brush · 2 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says the creamy plant-based wax blend volumizes without clumping, flaking or transferring
- Not waterproof
- Buildable from natural to full
Prices are the brands' US list prices, checked on November 17, 2026, and may have changed. We carry no shopping links and earn nothing when you buy.
How we test
We buy every mascara at full retail price from US retailers or the brand’s own site. A panel of 20 to 30 women aged 38 to 65 wears each mascara as directed for four weeks. On measurement days a technician applies two coats of one product to the right eye and two coats of a second product to the left, with no lash primer, so both formulas face the same day, the same skin and the same weather. Panelists are blinded to brand and do not know which product is on which eye.
We take standardized close-up photographs of each eye under fixed lighting at 2, 6 and 10 hours and score them for flakes on the cheek and lid, smudging below the lower lash line, and loss of definition. Lash length and separation are measured on the same images against the bare-lash baseline taken before application. Panelists record any stinging, dryness or watering during the day, then remove the mascara with their usual cleanser and rate how easily it comes off; residue is photographed.
Laura Schmidt, MD, FRCP, supervises the clinical sessions. The ingredient audit reviews the full ingredient list, the wand and the tube. Products are scored on efficacy, formula, feel and use, and value, and the Scientific Board reviews every score before publication.
The four criteria
- 40Efficacy
- Measured change against baseline: hydration, elasticity, wrinkle depth, pigmentation, SPF verification or wear performance, depending on the category.
- 25Formula
- Ingredient audit: evidence behind the actives, stated concentrations, stability and packaging that protects them.
- 20Feel & use
- Texture, absorption, scent, layering under other products, tolerance reported by the panel.
- 15Value
- What the measured performance costs per month at the brand's list price.
Who runs this test
-
Independent panel led by Professor Charlotte Weber, MD
-
Ingredient audit by Marcus Bauer, PhD
-
Clinical testing supervised by Laura Schmidt, MD, FRCP
Subscriber content
The results
Laboratory results for this test have not been published yet. When they are, the scores, ranking and findings for all 7 products will be available to subscribers.
- A score out of 100 for every product, across four criteria
- The ranking, with the Test Winner and every Highly Rated product
- Measured findings and a plain-English verdict for each product
Subscriptions are opening soon. Join the waiting list to be told first.