Skip to content

Independent. Reader-funded. No advertising. Since 1984.

How we are funded

Skincare Lab test

Exfoliating Acid Toners (AHA, BHA, PHA)

Seven exfoliating acid toners from $13.50 to $110. Over 8 weeks we measure changes in texture and tone and what each toner does to an aging skin barrier.

Products selected
7
Price range
$13.50 to $110
Scored out of
100
Results
Pending

Why we are testing these

Exfoliating toners are liquids applied after cleansing and left on the skin. Their acids loosen the bonds that hold dead cells to the surface so those cells shed sooner, which can make skin look smoother and more even. Three families dominate the shelf. Alpha hydroxy acids (AHAs) such as glycolic and lactic acid are water-soluble and work at the surface; glycolic acid has the most published data, including studies of photoaged skin. Beta hydroxy acid (BHA, salicylic acid) is oil-soluble and can clear pores. Polyhydroxy acids (PHAs) such as gluconolactone are larger molecules that penetrate more slowly and are marketed as gentler.

The confusion is real. A percentage on the label says little without the pH, which brands rarely disclose, and most products are sold for daily use even though an aging skin barrier recovers more slowly from over-exfoliation. AHAs also increase sun sensitivity, so daytime sunscreen is not optional.

Prices run from $13.50 to $110 for liquids that are mostly water. We wanted to know which formulas produce a measurable change in texture and tone, and which simply sting.

What we look for

  • Measurable improvement in surface texture and pore appearance in standardized images after 8 weeks
  • A visible effect on dullness and uneven pigmentation under cross-polarized light
  • No loss of barrier function: transepidermal water loss and corneometry readings that stay stable or improve
  • Tolerance on skin over 38: stinging, redness and flaking recorded daily
  • Disclosed acid type and concentration, and a formula whose supporting ingredients make sense for the strength
  • Packaging that limits evaporation and contamination, and a realistic cost per month at the directed dose

Free preview

The 7 products in this test

Listed alphabetically by brand, not ranked. The facts below come from each brand's own published information. Our own measurements will appear in the results.

  • Glow Recipe

    Watermelon Glow PHA+BHA Pore-Tight Toner

    $36 150 mL Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    PHA (gluconolactone) 3% + BHA (betaine salicylate) 2% · watermelon extract and cactus water blend 62% · glycerin 16%

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it hydrates and refines pores in one step, inspired by the Korean aqua peel facial
    • Brand cites a 31-subject clinical study in which 100% saw a significant reduction in pore size after 2 weeks
    • Alcohol-free and free of synthetic fragrance, according to the brand
    • Brand reports a 4-week consumer study of 30 people in which 97% agreed skin felt smoother and looked clearer
  • Kate Somerville

    Liquid ExfoliKate® Triple Acid Resurfacing Treatment

    $72 4 fl oz Prestige

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    triple acid blend 10% (glycolic, malic and lactic acids) · phytic acid with pumpkin, papaya and pineapple enzymes · tetra-peptide, honey and tea extract

    What the brand says

    • Brand describes it as a gentle nightly leave-on toner that dissolves dead skin buildup
    • Brand says texture looks smoother and pores smaller in as little as four weeks, and cites an independent clinical study in which 100% showed improvement in pore size after one use
    • Brand warns that the AHAs may increase sun sensitivity and advises sunscreen during use and for a week afterward
  • Medik8

    Press & Glow™

    $35 200 mL Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    gluconolactone (PHA)

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it is clinically proven to improve skin glow by 20% in 4 weeks, citing an independent study of 31 participants
    • Brand says it is gentle enough for twice-daily use, including on sensitive skin
    • Brand says it removes dead surface cells to smooth texture and improve absorption of vitamin C and vitamin A products
  • Omorovicza

    Acid Milk Toner

    $110 100 mL Prestige

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    glycolic, lactic, salicylic and azelaic acids (percentages not stated) · coastal microalgae · ceramides and oat kernel oil · Healing Concentrate (brand's patented Hungarian thermal water complex)

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it is clinically proven to increase radiance by 71% after one use
    • Brand says the leave-on resurfacing tonic brightens and smooths without irritation and is for all skin types
    • Brand directs use up to three times weekly
  • Paula's Choice Skin Perfecting 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant

    Paula's Choice

    Skin Perfecting 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant

    $37 4 fl oz Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    salicylic acid (BHA) 2%

    What the brand says

    • Brand says the daily salicylic acid toner quickly unclogs pores and controls oil
    • Brand calls it clinically proven and its best-selling product worldwide
    • Brand says it is suitable for daily use

    Image: Paula's Choice

  • The INKEY List

    PHA Toner

    $18 100 mL Drugstore

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    polyhydroxy acid (PHA, gluconolactone) 3% · niacinamide 3% · aloe vera

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it gently removes dead surface cells to improve uneven texture, dullness and the look of enlarged pores while maintaining hydration
    • Brand positions it as a milder alternative to glycolic acid for sensitive skin and for people new to chemical exfoliation
    • Brand recommends starting two to three times a week and using SPF by day
  • The Ordinary Glycolic Acid 7% Exfoliating Toner

    The Ordinary

    Glycolic Acid 7% Exfoliating Toner

    $13.50 240 mL Drugstore

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    glycolic acid 7% · aloe barbadensis leaf water · Panax ginseng root extract · Tasmannia lanceolata (Tasmanian pepperberry) fruit/leaf extract

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it smooths skin texture, evens tone and enhances luminosity
    • Brand says it targets textural irregularities, dullness and uneven skin tone and suits all skin types
    • Positioned by the brand as a daily, water-based toner

    Image: The Ordinary

Prices are the brands' US list prices, checked on November 17, 2026, and may have changed. We carry no shopping links and earn nothing when you buy.

How we test

We buy each toner at retail at full price. Because these are leave-on treatments, a panel of 20 to 30 women aged 38 to 65 uses each one for 8 weeks as directed, on one randomly assigned half of the face, with a plain hydrating toner on the other half as control. Brands are concealed. Every panelist uses the same unscented sunscreen each morning.

At weeks 0, 4 and 8 we photograph each face under standardized visible and cross-polarized light and grade texture, pore appearance, dullness and pigmentation with image analysis. We measure hydration by corneometry and barrier function by transepidermal water loss at the same sites, and panelists keep a daily diary of stinging, redness and flaking, including any product they had to pause.

Marcus Bauer, PhD audits each ingredient list, confirms disclosed acid concentrations where the brand states them, measures the pH of every formula in the lab and assesses packaging. Each product is scored on efficacy (40), formula (25), feel and use (20) and value (15), and the Scientific Board reviews the scores before publication.

The four criteria

40Efficacy
Measured change against baseline: hydration, elasticity, wrinkle depth, pigmentation, SPF verification or wear performance, depending on the category.
25Formula
Ingredient audit: evidence behind the actives, stated concentrations, stability and packaging that protects them.
20Feel & use
Texture, absorption, scent, layering under other products, tolerance reported by the panel.
15Value
What the measured performance costs per month at the brand's list price.

Our full testing method

Who runs this test

Subscriber content

The results

Laboratory results for this test have not been published yet. When they are, the scores, ranking and findings for all 7 products will be available to subscribers.

  • A score out of 100 for every product, across four criteria
  • The ranking, with the Test Winner and every Highly Rated product
  • Measured findings and a plain-English verdict for each product

See subscription plans

Subscriptions are opening soon. Join the waiting list to be told first.

Lab tests

All lab tests

Skincare Lab test

Cleansing Balms

8 products $12 to $85

Results pending

Skincare Lab test

Sheet Masks

6 products $5.99 to $115

Results pending

Subscriptions opening soon

Paid for by readers. Answerable to no one else.

A subscription will open the full results of all 50 lab tests: every score, every ranking and every finding. $7.99 a month or $59 a year, cancel anytime.

See what a subscription includes

Join the waiting list

One email when subscriptions open. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy.