Skincare Lab test
Cleansing Balms
Our test of eight cleansing balms from $12 to $85: how completely each removes long-wear makeup and sunscreen, and what it leaves behind on mature skin.
- Products selected
- 8
- Price range
- $12 to $85
- Scored out of
- 100
- Results
- Pending
Why we are testing these
A cleansing balm is a solid blend of oils, esters and waxes with an emulsifier. Massaged onto dry skin, it dissolves oil-based residue (long-wear foundation, waterproof mascara, sunscreen filters) and then turns milky with water so it can be rinsed away. For skin over 40, which produces less oil and loses water more easily, the appeal is obvious: a first cleanse that does not strip.
The confusion starts with the labels. Balms, cleansing oils and melting gels sit side by side at prices from $12 to more than $100, with little to tell a reader whether the expensive jar removes sunscreen any better than the drugstore tube. Some rinse clean; others leave a film that needs a second cleanser. Many are heavily fragranced with essential oils, which matters for skin that has become reactive with age, and most come in open jars scooped with the fingers.
Brands say their balms remove 99% of makeup or support the skin barrier, usually citing small in-house tests. We wanted to measure removal and the barrier effect directly, under identical conditions, across the price range.
What we look for
- Complete removal of a standardized long-wear foundation, waterproof mascara and SPF 50 sunscreen, measured by imaging rather than by eye
- How fully the balm emulsifies and rinses, and whether a residue remains that needs a second cleanser
- Skin hydration and transepidermal water loss 30 minutes after washing, compared with a reference cleanser
- Comfort around the eyes and on skin that is dry, thin or reactive
- Formula and packaging: oil and ester base, emulsifier type, added fragrance or essential oils, and whether the jar can be used hygienically
- Cost per gram against the amount needed for one full cleanse
Free preview
The 8 products in this test
Listed alphabetically by brand, not ranked. The facts below come from each brand's own published information. Our own measurements will appear in the results.
-

e.l.f. Cosmetics
Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm
$12 2 oz (56.5 g) Drugstore
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
hyaluronic acid · ceramides · peptides
What the brand says
- Brand says the solid balm melts into an oil, then a milky texture that rinses clean
- Brand says it removes makeup and leaves skin feeling silky smooth and soft
- Vegan and cruelty-free; brand says its products are free from phthalates, parabens and sulfates
Image: e.l.f. Cosmetics
-

ELEMIS
Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm
$75 100 g Prestige
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
padina pavonica (brown algae) · starflower oil · elderberry oil · Optimega oil blend · mimosa wax
What the brand says
- Brand says it is clinically proven to melt away waterproof and long-wear makeup
- Brand says it is clinically proven to give 24-hour skin barrier support
- Three textures in one: balm to oil to hydrating milk, and it can be left on as a mask
- Mineral-oil-free, with a blend of nine essential oils including lavender, chamomile and eucalyptus
Image: ELEMIS
-
EVE LOM
Cleanser
$85 100 mL (3.3 fl oz) Prestige
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
Lipid-Rich Barrier Complex (brand's name) · oil blend of eucalyptus, clove leaf, chamomile and hops · cocoa butter
What the brand says
- Brand says it removes makeup, cleanses, buffs, hydrates and primes skin in two minutes when used with its muslin cloth
- Brand cites a 2017 independent clinical trial on 22 people showing increased hydration and barrier support
- Brand says it is clinically proven non-comedogenic and dermatologist tested
-
Farmacy
Green Clean Cleansing Balm
$39 Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
super greens blend (upcycled moringa, holy basil and arugula) · sunflower oil · papaya extract
What the brand says
- Brand says it removes over 99% of long-wear lipstick, foundation, waterproof mascara and SPF after one cleanse
- Brand says 96% of users agreed skin felt smoother, softer and more hydrated after one cleanse
- Sold in Original, Fragrance-Free and Honey Vanilla scents
-

Neutrogena
Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm, Fragrance-Free
2.6 oz Drugstore
What the brand says
- Brand says it gently melts away dirt, oil and stubborn makeup, including waterproof mascara
- Brand says it is gentle enough for the sensitive eye area
- Fragrance-, paraben- and phthalate-free, according to the brand
Image: Neutrogena
-
Sunday Riley
Blue Moon Clean Rinse Cleansing Balm
$50 3.5 oz (100 g) Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
sugar-based cleansers · moringa butter and organic cocoa butter · blue tansy and German chamomile oils · tangerine and sweet orange essential oils
What the brand says
- Brand says it removes makeup and impurities, including stubborn eye makeup, with gentle sugar-based cleansers
- Brand says blue tansy and German chamomile help calm the look of irritated, dry, flaky skin
- Brand labels it fragrance-free although the formula is scented with essential oils
-
The INKEY List
Oat Cleansing Balm
$17 150 mL Drugstore
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
oat kernel oil 5% · sea buckthorn oil
What the brand says
- Brand says it melts makeup and SPF in 30 seconds, citing a 29-person consumer trial
- Brand says it is clinically proven to support skin barrier function (29 participants, 4 weeks) and to leave skin hydrated for up to 12 hours (23 participants)
- Accepted by the National Eczema Association and suitable for sensitive eyes, according to the brand; packaged in a squeeze tube
-
Then I Met You
Living Cleansing Balm
$39 90 g Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
grape seed, olive and seaberry (sea buckthorn) oils · persimmon extract · vitamin E
What the brand says
- Brand says it melts away sunscreen, makeup, excess sebum and other oil-based impurities without stripping skin or irritating the eyes
- Brand describes a sorbet-soft first cleanse scented with rosemary, persimmon and grapefruit
- Brand says the oil blend of olive and sea buckthorn supports a compromised skin barrier
Prices are the brands' US list prices, checked on November 17, 2026, and may have changed. We carry no shopping links and earn nothing when you buy.
How we test
We buy every balm at retail at full price. Because a cleanser is rinsed off, the panel period is 4 weeks: 20 to 30 women aged 38 to 65 use each product every evening as directed, with the brand concealed. Each woman tests two products, one on each half of the face, assigned at random.
Removal is measured in the lab. We apply a fixed amount of a long-wear foundation, waterproof mascara and an SPF 50 sunscreen to standardized areas, photograph them under visible, cross-polarized and UV light, cleanse for a timed 60 seconds with a measured dose of balm, rinse, and photograph again. Software scores the pigment and sunscreen residue that remains. We also time how quickly each balm emulsifies and record any film left on the skin. At weeks 0 and 4 we read hydration by corneometry and transepidermal water loss 30 minutes after washing, and panelists log eye comfort, stinging and dryness daily.
Marcus Bauer, PhD audits each full ingredient list, including fragrance and essential-oil content, and assesses the packaging. Products are scored on efficacy (40), formula (25), feel and use (20) and value (15), with every score reviewed by the Scientific Board.
The four criteria
- 40Efficacy
- Measured change against baseline: hydration, elasticity, wrinkle depth, pigmentation, SPF verification or wear performance, depending on the category.
- 25Formula
- Ingredient audit: evidence behind the actives, stated concentrations, stability and packaging that protects them.
- 20Feel & use
- Texture, absorption, scent, layering under other products, tolerance reported by the panel.
- 15Value
- What the measured performance costs per month at the brand's list price.
Who runs this test
-
Independent panel led by Professor Charlotte Weber, MD
-
Ingredient audit by Marcus Bauer, PhD
-
Clinical testing supervised by Laura Schmidt, MD, FRCP
Subscriber content
The results
Laboratory results for this test have not been published yet. When they are, the scores, ranking and findings for all 8 products will be available to subscribers.
- A score out of 100 for every product, across four criteria
- The ranking, with the Test Winner and every Highly Rated product
- Measured findings and a plain-English verdict for each product
Subscriptions are opening soon. Join the waiting list to be told first.





