Makeup Lab test
Brow Pencils and Gels
Seven brow pencils and gels from $6 to $63. We assess natural-looking definition, wear through the day and ease of use on brows that have thinned.
- Products selected
- 7
- Price range
- $6 to $63
- Scored out of
- 100
- Results
- Pending
Why we are testing these
Brows thin with age. Hairs grow in more slowly, the tail of the brow often disappears first, and the remaining hairs can turn gray or coarse. Because brows frame the eyes, the change shows quickly, and a well-defined brow does more for a mature face than most other makeup. It also goes wrong easily: a pencil that is too dark or too waxy reads as drawn on, and a gel that holds like glue looks stiff by noon.
The shelf offers more choice than ever and little guidance. Micro-tip pencils promise hair-like strokes; tinted gels with fibers promise fullness; pomades and mousses promise hold without crunch. Shade ranges run from four to twelve, and the right choice for gray or blonde brows is rarely obvious. Prices run from $6 to more than $60, and only one product from the brands we considered sits above that line.
We chose seven products sold in the US, four pencils and three gels or mousses, across those price tiers. We buy every one at retail. The test asks how natural each looks, how long it stays where it is put, and how it behaves on sparse brows over a working day.
What we look for
- How natural the result looks on sparse and partially gray brows, judged from standardized images immediately after application
- Fading, smudging and transfer at 2, 6 and 10 hours, including after the brow is touched
- Precision of the tip or brush, and how easily the product builds without looking heavy
- Hold and stiffness of gels and mousses through the day, and whether they flake
- Shade range, including options for gray, blonde and red brows
- Ingredient list, amount of product in the package, and price per gram
Free preview
The 7 products in this test
Listed alphabetically by brand, not ranked. The facts below come from each brand's own published information. Our own measurements will appear in the results.
-
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Brow Wiz
$26 0.003 oz (0.085 g) Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
dry wax formula · 1 mm ultra-fine retractable tip · custom spoolie · 11 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says the ultra-fine 1 mm tip creates hair-like strokes in sparse areas
- Wax formula delivers high color payoff and mimics hair-like texture
-
Benefit Cosmetics
Precisely, My Brow Pencil
$28 0.002 oz (0.08 g) Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
ultra-fine twist-up tip · built-in spoolie · 12 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says it draws natural-looking, hair-like strokes for precisely defined brows
- Waterproof and smudge-proof
- 12 shades including options for red, blonde and gray hair
-
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Wow Brow Gel
$6 Drugstore
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
wax-gel hybrid · kaolin clay · hair-like fibers · 5 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says the buildable, fiber-infused tinted gel makes natural brows look fuller
- Kaolin clay and hair-like fibers adhere to and enhance brows
-
Maybelline New York
Brow Ultra Slim
$9.99 Drugstore
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
1.5 mm micro tip · wax formula · built-in spoolie · 9 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says it gives up to 16 hours of fade-resistant color
- Smudge-, water- and sweat-resistant
- Break-resistant 1.5 mm tip for fine, hair-like strokes
-
MERIT
Brow 1980
$24 4.5 g Drugstore
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
volumizing pomade · light, flexible hold · 4 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says it gives soft, fluffy brows with light hold and zero crunchiness
- Adds color and volume while shaping and grooming with a lasting, flexible hold
-
TOM FORD
Brow Sculptor
$63 0.02 oz Prestige
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
pencil with grooming brush · 5 shades
What the brand says
- Brand says a groomed and shaped brow is the most powerful, non-invasive way to define and enhance facial features
- Sold in Taupe, Blonde, Granite, Chestnut and Espresso
-
Westman Atelier
Bonne Brow Defining Pencil
$38 0.01 oz (0.34 g) Mid-range
Key ingredients, as stated by the brand
100% naturally derived pigments · detachable dry spoolie · 4 shades (Bark, Clay, Stone, Slate)
What the brand says
- Brand says the firm-yet-gentle formula glides on evenly to mimic hair-like strokes
- Buildable finish from soft and defined to bold and full
Prices are the brands' US list prices, checked on November 17, 2026, and may have changed. We carry no shopping links and earn nothing when you buy.
How we test
We buy every product at full retail price from US retailers or the brand’s own site. A panel of 20 to 30 women aged 38 to 65 uses each product as directed for four weeks, applying it to both brows themselves so that we also capture how easy it is to use at home. On measurement days a technician applies one product to the right brow and a second product to the left, in shades matched to each panelist, so that both face the same day and the same skin. Panelists are blinded to brand.
We take standardized close-up photographs of both brows under fixed lighting immediately after application and at 2, 6 and 10 hours, and score them for fading, smudging, flaking of gel or fibers, and migration of color into the skin. At 6 hours panelists rub each brow once with a fingertip to test transfer. Panelists record how the product feels, whether gels stiffen or itch, and how easily the product removes at night.
Laura Schmidt, MD, FRCP, supervises the clinical sessions. The ingredient audit reviews the full ingredient list, the tip or brush design and the amount of product in the package. Products are scored on efficacy, formula, feel and use, and value, and the Scientific Board reviews every score before publication.
The four criteria
- 40Efficacy
- Measured change against baseline: hydration, elasticity, wrinkle depth, pigmentation, SPF verification or wear performance, depending on the category.
- 25Formula
- Ingredient audit: evidence behind the actives, stated concentrations, stability and packaging that protects them.
- 20Feel & use
- Texture, absorption, scent, layering under other products, tolerance reported by the panel.
- 15Value
- What the measured performance costs per month at the brand's list price.
Who runs this test
-
Independent panel led by Professor Charlotte Weber, MD
-
Ingredient audit by Marcus Bauer, PhD
-
Clinical testing supervised by Laura Schmidt, MD, FRCP
Subscriber content
The results
Laboratory results for this test have not been published yet. When they are, the scores, ranking and findings for all 7 products will be available to subscribers.
- A score out of 100 for every product, across four criteria
- The ranking, with the Test Winner and every Highly Rated product
- Measured findings and a plain-English verdict for each product
Subscriptions are opening soon. Join the waiting list to be told first.