Skip to content

Independent. Reader-funded. No advertising. Since 1984.

How we are funded

Skincare Lab test

Gentle Cleansers for Mature Skin

Seven gentle cleansers from $12.50 to $79. We measure how well they remove makeup and sunscreen without leaving skin over 40 drier than before.

Products selected
7
Price range
$12.50 to $79
Scored out of
100
Results
Pending

Why we are testing these

After 40, skin makes less sebum and holds water less well, so the cleanser that felt fine at 30 can leave a face tight, flaky and more reactive. Gentle is the most common promise on the shelf, but it is not a regulated term. It can mean a low-foaming cream, a sulfate-free gel, a milky lotion or simply a lower fragrance load.

The mechanism is the same in every case. Surfactants (cleansing agents with an oil-loving end and a water-loving end) surround oil, makeup and sunscreen so that water can carry them away. Milder surfactants and added humectants such as glycerin remove less of the skin’s own lipids, but they may also leave more sunscreen behind. That trade-off between a thorough cleanse and an intact barrier is exactly what a shopper cannot read from the label, and prices run from $12.50 to $79 for products that are mostly water.

We test cleansers across the price range on the removal of long-wear makeup and sunscreen, and on what the skin measures like half an hour later.

What we look for

  • Removal of a standardized long-wear foundation and SPF 50 sunscreen, measured by imaging
  • Skin hydration and transepidermal water loss 30 minutes after washing, compared with washing with water alone
  • Comfort on dry, thin or reactive skin: tightness, stinging and eye comfort recorded daily
  • Surfactant system and pH, added fragrance or essential oils, and any actives the brand highlights
  • Rinsability and residue, and how much product one wash needs
  • Cost per wash, including the amount needed to remove sunscreen

Free preview

The 7 products in this test

Listed alphabetically by brand, not ranked. The facts below come from each brand's own published information. Our own measurements will appear in the results.

  • CeraVe Hydrating Facial Cleanser

    CeraVe

    Hydrating Facial Cleanser

    $15.99 12 oz Drugstore

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    ceramides (ceramide NP, AP and EOP) · hyaluronic acid (sodium hyaluronate) · glycerin

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it washes away dirt, oil and impurities without stripping skin or leaving it tight and dry
    • Developed with dermatologists for normal to dry skin, according to the brand
    • Brand says it helps restore and maintain the skin's natural moisture barrier

    Image: CeraVe

  • Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser

    Cetaphil

    Gentle Skin Cleanser

    Drugstore

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    niacinamide (vitamin B3) · panthenol (vitamin B5) · glycerin

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it is clinically proven to leave skin hydrated after cleansing and to provide continuous hydration
    • Cream formula with micellar technology that the brand says removes dirt, makeup and impurities
    • Brand says 95% of users felt it gently cleansed their skin; dermatologist tested and clinically proven gentle on sensitive skin

    Image: Cetaphil

  • Murad

    Renewing Cleansing Cream

    $38 5.0 fl oz Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    lactic acid · peptide (unnamed) · vitamin E · apricot and starflower oils · essential fatty acids from evening primrose and apricot oil

    What the brand says

    • Brand says the silky cream transforms into a non-drying lather that lifts away oils and impurities
    • Brand says gentle lactic acid, a peptide and vitamin E help smooth and renew skin
    • Brand lists it for balanced, combination and dry skin
  • Shiseido

    Future Solution LX Extra Rich Cleansing Foam

    $79 125 mL Prestige

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    Japanese enmei herb extract · N-methyltaurine (NMT)

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it removes impurities while maintaining skin's moisture and leaves a protective, hydrating veil
    • Brand says it preps skin to better absorb the products that follow
    • Brand cites a consumer test of 111 women: in 1 week 90% saw plumper skin and in 2 weeks 92% saw brighter skin
    • Dermatologist tested and non-comedogenic, according to the brand
  • Sunday Riley

    Ceramic Slip Cleanser

    $35 5.0 fl oz (150 mL) Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    French green clay, bentonite and white kaolin · rice and olive oil esters · blend of four plant-based soaps (brand's description)

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it lifts away dirt and impurities without stripping the skin and can be used daily, morning and night
    • Brand says clays pull oil, pollution and makeup from pores while rice oil esters protect against dehydration
    • Sulfate-free, fragrance-free and vegan, according to the brand
  • Tata Harper

    Superkind Softening Cleanser

    $78 125 mL Prestige

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    plant surfactants · maracuja (passion fruit) seed oil · phytosqualane and diglycerin · Tetra Lipid Complex (phytosqualane, apple seed, grapeseed and evening primrose oils) · oat seed oil

    What the brand says

    • Brand describes it as a soothing, milky gel cleanser that lifts away impurities with mild plant-based surfactants without stripping
    • Brand says the formula is 100% natural origin by Ecocert COSMOS standards, hypoallergenic and fragrance-free, with no essential oils, sulfates or harsh exfoliants
    • Dermatologist tested and accepted by the National Eczema Association, according to the brand
  • The Ordinary Glycolipid Cream Cleanser

    The Ordinary

    Glycolipid Cream Cleanser

    $12.50 150 mL Drugstore

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    glycolipids

    What the brand says

    • Brand says the gentle cream cleanser effectively removes makeup, including foundation, eyeliner and mascara
    • Brand lists it for cleansing and barrier support and says it suits all skin types
    • Alcohol-free, oil-free, silicone-free and vegan, according to the brand

    Image: The Ordinary

Prices are the brands' US list prices, checked on November 17, 2026, and may have changed. We carry no shopping links and earn nothing when you buy.

How we test

We buy every cleanser at retail at full price. As rinse-off products, cleansers follow the 4-week protocol: a panel of 20 to 30 women aged 38 to 65 uses each product morning and evening as directed, with the brand concealed. Each woman tests two cleansers, one on each half of the face, assigned at random.

Removal is measured in the lab on standardized skin areas. We apply fixed amounts of a long-wear foundation and an SPF 50 sunscreen, photograph under visible, cross-polarized and UV light, cleanse for a timed 30 seconds with a measured dose, rinse and photograph again; software scores the residue. At weeks 0 and 4 we read hydration by corneometry and transepidermal water loss 30 minutes after washing, alongside a water-only control site. Panelists log tightness, stinging, eye comfort and flaking every day.

Marcus Bauer, PhD audits each full ingredient list, identifies the surfactant system, measures the pH and assesses packaging, including pump hygiene. Laura Schmidt, MD, FRCP supervises the clinical arm. Products are scored on efficacy (40), formula (25), feel and use (20) and value (15), and the Scientific Board reviews every score.

The four criteria

40Efficacy
Measured change against baseline: hydration, elasticity, wrinkle depth, pigmentation, SPF verification or wear performance, depending on the category.
25Formula
Ingredient audit: evidence behind the actives, stated concentrations, stability and packaging that protects them.
20Feel & use
Texture, absorption, scent, layering under other products, tolerance reported by the panel.
15Value
What the measured performance costs per month at the brand's list price.

Our full testing method

Who runs this test

Subscriber content

The results

Laboratory results for this test have not been published yet. When they are, the scores, ranking and findings for all 7 products will be available to subscribers.

  • A score out of 100 for every product, across four criteria
  • The ranking, with the Test Winner and every Highly Rated product
  • Measured findings and a plain-English verdict for each product

See subscription plans

Subscriptions are opening soon. Join the waiting list to be told first.

Lab tests

All lab tests

Skincare Lab test

Sheet Masks

6 products $5.99 to $115

Results pending

Subscriptions opening soon

Paid for by readers. Answerable to no one else.

A subscription will open the full results of all 50 lab tests: every score, every ranking and every finding. $7.99 a month or $59 a year, cancel anytime.

See what a subscription includes

Join the waiting list

One email when subscriptions open. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy.