Skip to content

Independent. Reader-funded. No advertising. Since 1984.

How we are funded

Skincare Lab test

Bakuchiol and Retinol Alternatives on Trial

Six bakuchiol and plant-based retinol alternatives, from drugstore to prestige, go through eight weeks of instrumented testing against the claims printed on their labels.

Products selected
6
Price range
$19.99 to $80
Scored out of
100
Results
Pending

Why we are testing these

Retinol is the best-studied topical ingredient for signs of aging, but many readers cannot or will not use it. It can cause dryness, peeling and redness, especially in the first weeks, and it is not recommended during pregnancy or breastfeeding. That gap has created a fast-growing market for “retinol alternatives,” led by bakuchiol, an antioxidant extracted from the seeds and leaves of the babchi plant (Psoralea corylifolia).

Bakuchiol is not chemically related to retinol. The case for it rests on laboratory work suggesting it influences some of the same skin pathways, and on one small clinical trial: Dhaliwal et al. (2019), British Journal of Dermatology, doi:10.1111/bjd.16918. Forty-four volunteers used either 0.5% bakuchiol twice daily or 0.5% retinol once daily for 12 weeks. Both groups improved to a comparable degree in wrinkles and pigmentation, and the bakuchiol group reported less scaling and stinging. That is encouraging, but it is a single study, and the products on shelves vary widely in bakuchiol concentration, which most brands do not disclose.

The confusion is compounded by “retinol alternative” labels on products built around other things entirely: peptides, plant extracts, or blends in which bakuchiol is one of several actives, sometimes alongside retinol itself. This test takes six products sold as alternatives to retinol and asks whether they measurably change skin over eight weeks.

What we look for

  • Whether the brand states a bakuchiol concentration, and whether the formula is retinol-free or combines bakuchiol with a retinoid
  • Measured change in fine lines and texture on standardized imaging after 8 weeks
  • Skin hydration and transepidermal water loss, to see whether the product disturbs or supports the barrier
  • Tolerability: redness, stinging and flaking recorded by the panel, compared with what is typical for retinol
  • Packaging that protects a plant-derived antioxidant from light and air
  • Price per month of use at the directed amount

Free preview

The 6 products in this test

Listed alphabetically by brand, not ranked. The facts below come from each brand's own published information. Our own measurements will appear in the results.

  • Alpyn Beauty

    Melt Moisturizer

    $60 Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    bakuchiol · ceramides · hyaluronic acid · squalane

    What the brand says

    • Melts in with a velvety, makeup-ready finish
    • Hydrates and nourishes dry skin with hyaluronic acid, squalane and wild plants
    • Brand describes bakuchiol as a phyto-retinol that targets the look of fine lines and wrinkles
    • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Burt's Bees

    Renewal Intensive Firming Serum

    $19.99 1 oz (28.3 g) Drugstore

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    bakuchiol

    What the brand says

    • Brand says it is clinically shown to firm skin and reduce the appearance of deep lines and wrinkles with bakuchiol
    • Improves skin's elasticity and smooths the look of deep lines and wrinkles
    • 98% natural origin
    • Works with the skin's natural moisture barrier
  • Herbivore Botanicals

    BAKUCHIOL Dual-Retinol Alternative Face Serum

    $68 30 mL Prestige

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    two forms of bakuchiol · Chios mastic tree resin

    What the brand says

    • Smooths and firms the appearance of skin; designed for a nightly routine
    • Two forms of bakuchiol said to mimic the effects of a traditional retinol in a formula designed to be gentle
    • After 2 weeks, 100% of panelists showed a reduction in fine lines and wrinkles (brand expert-graded test, 30 participants)
    • 97% showed an improvement in firmness and elasticity in the same test
  • Herbivore Botanicals

    MOON DEW 1% Bakuchiol + Peptides Retinol Alternative Eye Cream

    $48 15 mL Mid-range

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    bakuchiol 1% · plant peptides · vegan squalane

    What the brand says

    • Firming eye cream for the skin around the entire eye area
    • 1% bakuchiol and plant peptides to diminish the look of fine lines and wrinkles
    • Delivers an instant tightening effect
    • Brand describes it as a clinically proven, plant-based retinol alternative that improves texture and elasticity
  • KORA Organics

    Plant Stem Cell Retinol Alternative Serum

    $80 1.01 fl oz (30 mL) Prestige

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    5% retinol-alternative blend of bakuchiol and alfalfa extract · acai stem cells · noni fruit · rosehip oil

    What the brand says

    • Milky dual-action serum that smooths wrinkles and firms skin with antioxidant protection
    • Gentle enough to use day and night without irritation, redness or dryness, according to the brand
    • Nearly 80% of retinol users said it performed better than traditional retinol alone (brand survey)
    • Certified organic
  • Paula's Choice

    CLINICAL 0.3% Retinol + 2% Bakuchiol Treatment

    $65 1 fl. oz. Prestige

    Key ingredients, as stated by the brand

    retinol 0.3% · bakuchiol 2% · peptides

    What the brand says

    • Mid-strength 0.3% retinol targets fine lines and deep wrinkles
    • Brand says 2% bakuchiol amplifies retinol's wrinkle-fighting power
    • Peptides support healthy collagen for improved firmness
    • Light lotion texture that absorbs quickly

Prices are the brands' US list prices, checked on November 17, 2026, and may have changed. We carry no shopping links and earn nothing when you buy.

How we test

We buy every product at retail, at full price, from US stores or the brand’s own site. Nothing is accepted from brands. Marcus Bauer, PhD audits each ingredient list, checks any concentration the brand discloses, and assesses whether the packaging protects the formula from light and air.

A panel of 20 to 30 women aged 38 to 65 then uses each product as directed for 8 weeks, blinded to brand. Where the format allows, each volunteer applies the test product to one side of the face and a plain moisturizer to the other, so the two halves can be compared. Before the test, at 4 weeks and at 8 weeks we measure skin hydration by corneometry, elasticity by cutometry and transepidermal water loss, and we photograph each face under standardized lighting to grade wrinkles, texture and pigmentation. Volunteers record any redness, stinging or flaking in a daily diary.

Professor Charlotte Weber, MD leads the independent panel, and Laura Schmidt, MD, FRCP supervises the clinical sites. Each product is scored on Efficacy (40 points), Formula (25), Feel and use (20) and Value (15), and the Scientific Board reviews every score before publication.

The four criteria

40Efficacy
Measured change against baseline: hydration, elasticity, wrinkle depth, pigmentation, SPF verification or wear performance, depending on the category.
25Formula
Ingredient audit: evidence behind the actives, stated concentrations, stability and packaging that protects them.
20Feel & use
Texture, absorption, scent, layering under other products, tolerance reported by the panel.
15Value
What the measured performance costs per month at the brand's list price.

Our full testing method

Who runs this test

Subscriber content

The results

Laboratory results for this test have not been published yet. When they are, the scores, ranking and findings for all 6 products will be available to subscribers.

  • A score out of 100 for every product, across four criteria
  • The ranking, with the Test Winner and every Highly Rated product
  • Measured findings and a plain-English verdict for each product

See subscription plans

Subscriptions are opening soon. Join the waiting list to be told first.

Lab tests

All lab tests

Subscriptions opening soon

Paid for by readers. Answerable to no one else.

A subscription will open the full results of all 50 lab tests: every score, every ranking and every finding. $7.99 a month or $59 a year, cancel anytime.

See what a subscription includes

Join the waiting list

One email when subscriptions open. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy.